Immigration Reform
Question
Despite the careful and tedious process of rulemaking, there is always going to be someone who is unhappy with the regulation in its entirety. Accordingly, the door is always open for reform; a chance to improve the regulation by altering it, or by somehow correcting perceived errors. In essence, reform will change the condition of the current administrative law. Can you reflect on the number of times that this has happened recently? Is it easier to reform that which is flawed, or is it better to just start from the beginning?
In preparation for this Assignment, select one of the following situations:
1.You are an appointed member of the White House Special Council staff.
2. You are an international analyst (outside of the United States).
To complete the Assignment:
In the role you selected, draft a 3- to 4-page on an immigration reform, economic trade, environmental, or human trafficking proposal regarding a rule that the president or nation is seeking to change.
Your proposal should include the Bluebook citation of the rule the president or the nation is seeking to reform, as well as a persuasive argument for the need for reform of the rule.
Support your position using a minimum of 4 scholarly resources.


Solution
Immigration Reform
The
issue of immigration is one of the most contentious in the current political
climate in the United States. Over the years, leaders of all governments and
policymakers have assessed the economic, security, and humanitarian
implications of immigration. Congress, the constitutionally required
legislative body, has struggled to adopt significant immigration legislation.
Significant decisions on immigration have been executed by the administration,
with the court having an essential role in establishing their legality and
constitutionality. For immigration reform in the United States, this idea
serves as a framework. Immigrants who have been in the country illegally for a
long time should be allowed to earn their way to citizenship via an earned
path. Therefore, the Immigration
Reform Bill under US Citizenship Act 2022 is a contentious bill that needs
to be passed to solve the citizenship menace in United States
In
an effective immigration agency, there can never be more than 11 million
illegal immigrants. Undocumented immigrants should be able to apply for
temporary legal status and then apply for citizenship after working in the US
for several years and meeting criminal and national security conditions.
Immigrant integration is hindered if newcomers are required to work for at
least seven years before applying for citizenship (Loweree
& Reichlin-Melnick, 2021). People in the West believe that citizenship
should be acquired rather than a right. As a result, it is more difficult to
get but simpler to lose one’s gained citizenship. The law should check at
reducing the number of illegal immigrants and eradicate neoliberal explanations
that lead to the idea that citizenship is a luxury rather than a privilege. It
is necessary to put in place the process of acquiring citizenship (Sheridan n.d). An important distinction is that
these processes aim not to expedite the naturalization process for newcomers
but rather to promote equity and justice for everyone.
Following a period of five years in a
temporary status, individuals would be entitled to apply for a green card and
then gain citizenship three years later providing they cleared verification
process and paid their taxes (Bhargava, 2021). Having a diversified population
has helped the United States much. Creative and innovative thinking,
entrepreneurship, and the creation of new markets are all fostered by
diversity. As a result of embracing diversity as part of immigration reforms,
the United States now has a population more varied than any other country.
Immigrants worldwide are likely to boost economic activity, desire, and a wide
range of viewpoints and behaviors provided routes are created to assist their
arrival (Bhargava, 2021). As the US has an unsurpassed competitive advantage in
a fast globalizing economy, the adoption of diversity-stifling policies, such
as a return to the quota system of immigration that was extensively used in the
1920s, should be considered retrogressive.
It
is vital to provide legal documents to immigrants to keep families together.
Families might be torn apart if deportations are used against illegal
immigrants who have children born here in the United States. Deportation, after
all, is not a logical option since it would result in significant economic
losses due to the exodus of labor. According to current financial projections,
immigrant workers make up 4.6 percent of the workforce in the United States (Ries, 2020). In addition, illegal workers provide
a market for American products and services by paying billions of dollars in
taxes each year. When dealing with the problem of unauthorized immigrants, some
form of amnesty is necessary. To achieve this goal, the United States should
expedite the documentation of immigrants who qualify for legal status based on
familial links, particularly those who have met the wait time criterion (Wroe, 2022). Illegal immigrants whose relatives
are American citizens should be treated the same way. Temporary worker visas
should be offered to working immigrants who may have difficulty completing
legal family requirements. Immigrants’ social and economic needs must be
considered while implementing these policies, which may be reasonable and fair.
Current illegal immigrants should be eligible for social benefits until the
issuance of proper papers.
Deferred
Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) protections, a group known as “Dreamers,”
who came to United States unlawfully as children, farmworkers and persons
with Temporary Protected Status may apply immediately for a green card provided
they satisfy particular standards. In order to become a citizen, they
would need to wait three years.US Citizens need to address issues that foster
nativism and anti-immigration sentiments to reap the advantages of diversity.
Immigrants should be tested for their abilities to find work upon arrival.
Immigrant workers need to be evaluated to ensure they are valuable assets to
the American workforce (WEISHAR n.d). Nationalist
sentiment is lessened by giving preference to immigrants who work in fields
that Americans are less interested in. Although such a procedure might be seen
as discriminatory, it is necessary to protect domestic employees from the
fierce competition they face from foreign labor. Economic contributors,
immigrants should not compete with each other in the labor market but instead
be seen as complementary (Bhargava, 2021). An immigrant’s potential
contribution to the economy may be assessed via an admission exam.
Finally,
Congress has failed the country by failing to enact strong immigration laws.
Illegal immigrants have increased as a result. However, they threaten national
and international security, even if they bring economic benefits. Reforms in
immigration are required if the concerns of the US and those seeking
opportunity are to be furthered. For immigration reform, affirming diversity,
providing proof of employability, creating access to citizenship, and
maintaining family unity is critical.
References
Bhargava, D. (2021, September). Social
Democracy or Fortress Democracy? A Twenty-First Century Immigration Plan. In New Labor Forum (Vol. 30, No. 3, pp.
8-18). Sage CA: Los Angeles, CA: SAGE Publications. Retrieved April 17, 2022 from https://doi.org/10.1177/10957960211036021
Loweree, J., & Reichlin-Melnick, A.
(2021). Tracking the Biden agenda on legal immigration in the first 100 days. Retrieved April 17, 2022 from https://immigrationstrategies.issuelab.org/resources/38817/38817.pdf
Ries, L. (2020). President Trump and Joe
Biden: Comparing Immigration Policies. Backgrounder,
Center for Technology Policy, the Heritage Foundation, 3547. Retrieved April 17, 2022 from https://www.heritage.org/sites/default/files/2020-10/BG3547.pdf
Sheridan, M. B. IMMIGRATION AND MIGRATION. DOI: Retrieved
April 17, 2022 from https://doi.org/10.1017/ajil.2021.15
WEISHAR, S. IMMIGRATION REFORM AT LAST? Retrieved April 17, 2022 from https://jsri.loyno.edu/sites/loyno.edu.jsri/files/JSRI%20Newsletter%20Spring%202021_Weishar.pdf
Wroe, A. (2022). Immigration Policy. In Developments in American Politics 9 (pp.
207-230). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. Retrieved April 17,
2022 from https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-89740-6_13




About Author
Tough Essay Due? Hire Tough Essay Writers!
We have subject matter experts ready 24/7 to tackle your specific tasks and deliver them ON TIME, ready to hand in. Our writers have advanced degrees, and they know exactly what’s required to get you the best possible grade.
Find the right expert among 500+
We hire Gradewriters writers from different fields, thoroughly check their credentials, and put them through trials.
View all writers